Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Sinas Chinam XII – One-Way Correspondence – Final Email: Travesty of Justice

 


When a person kills another human being, this is called an act of homicide. In fact, the very definition of homicide is: causing the death of another human being.


In general, homicide is a very evil act. However, occasionally it is seen as what we call justifiable homicide. Usually, the rare justification is to commit homicide in defense of another human being that is threatened by the deceased or judicial execution. This does not mean it is not an act of homicide. It may not be criminal homicide but it is still homicide. One cannot undefine the meaning of the word and the act is a reality. This is the reason it is not easy to recruit a normal person to pull the lever on a convicted crook. Normal people do not prefer to commit homicide, even when it can be deemed justified.


Mesira (or malshinus), which is another way to harm another person, is exactly the same. The definition of mesira is the act of disclosing the actions or whereabouts of one person, or of his possessions, to a hostile entity (other than to a Jewish Beis Din). Likewise, this is considered a very evil act.


Just as likewise, it can occasionally be seen as a justified mesira. This is solely if it is the only way to save other people from imminent bodily or financial harm. There is no other justification. Just like homicide, even when there is justification for the mesira, it is still, and will always be an act of mesira. Again, we cannot undefine the action. The act is a reality.


There can be no dispute that what Nicole Meyer and her sisters committed is an act of mesira. It is a reality that meets the definition. It is also an act of gonev nefesh m’Yisrael which is a capital crime, and an act of extradition to chutz l’aretz (lo tasgir). There is a much more extensive list in my Kalman the Konsumer post (motzi shem rah, nekama, netira and, of course, chillul Hashem). The only question can be, is it a justified mesira? A justified gonev nefesh? A justified lo tasgir? (A justified chillul Hashem?)


I will start by saying that there is no justification to extradite a Jewish person outside of Eretz Yisrael whatsoever. No matter what! The gonev nefesh we can say is the result of the mesira and, hence, it comes as a package.


I noted countless times that the only justification for mesira is to save other people from imminent harm. And this, per Chofetz Chaim, is if there is no other way to accomplish this. To this, I even have the agreement for Rabbi Shay Schachter on Amudim’s own website (HERE 24:25), even though he mistakenly downplays this for SA cases.


None of this is applicable in the case of Malka Leifer and Nicole Meyer. As such, there can be nothing more despicable than to see a “Chareidi” Jewish organization and a respected Orthodox Rabbi host a forum supporting and idolizing an “Orthodox” woman who proudly and unabashedly boasts about doing all of these severe transgressions, not to mention to ask the room for a “standing ovation”.


What was the excuse used to justify this mesira, gonev nefesh, lo tasgir and chillul Hashem? Was it to save anyone from imminent harm?


Not at all. Nobody was in harm’s way and needed to be saved. Not Nicole, any of her sisters, or anybody in all of Australia. Mrs. Leifer was oceans away.


So why was it done?


It was done in order to get “Justice”.


Zvi Gluck first says it at only 18 seconds:


For years, these three sisters fought for justice. They faced enormous pressure, disbelief, attempts to silence them.

 

Rabbi Daniel Coren at 1 minute 15 seconds:

 

to be able to come and be able to bring much more emes and justice to the world.

 

The presenter Moshe Frankel beginning at 2:25:


the pain the heartache the fight for justice…(3:00) The challenges, the anguish and despair in seeking justice… even the recognition that sometimes justice fails or doesn't fully, isn't fully meted out… The Torah tells us in many places to seek justice…(4:33) On and on, the Torah emphasized the imperative to ensure justice…(10:44) Maybe it won't take 13 years to get justice.

 

Zvi Gluck again at 12:02:


Tonight is about courage. It's about justice.

 

At 13:06:


And later this evening, we will hear from someone whose courage helped bring justice not only for herself but for countless others, Nechama Meyer. Nechama, together with her sisters, Dassi and Ellie, fought a battle that lasted for years in order to bring Malka Leifer to justice.


At 17:00:


For years, these three sisters fought for justice. Not days, not months, years.


And then, there is Nicole (Nechama), herself. At 39:26 she quotes some sage advice from her late sister, A"H:


And whoever says what you're doing is a Chillul Hashem, Malka Leifer is doing a chillul Hashem by escaping justice, not you.

 

Comment - I think her sister (A”H) needed to be schooled on what makes a chillul Hashem. It doesn’t work like in kindergarten – “It’s your chillul Hashem, not my chillul Hashem, na-na-na-na-na”. Chillul Hashem is not mutually exclusive, there is enough opportunity for everyone. But, aside from that, can “Chams” please let us know exactly what Mrs. Leifer did in 2014 or any year since at least 2008 to constitute a chillul Hashem??


Then a little later on we have “obstructing justice”, “avoiding justice”, “fighting for justice”. 


And, at 48:34:


That is something I questioned myself because fighting for justice for so long and at some point, it felt like I was living for justice because of the pain of the delays and all the hardships that my sisters and I went through to try and get that justice.


Evidently, it’s all about justice.


Sounds nice (which is why they said it) except for two glaring problems.


Problem 1 – Even if it is authentic valid justice, it still does not legitimize mesira to goyim, gonev nefesh, extradition to chu”l, Nicole’s chillul Hashem and a host of other transgressions.


Problem 2 – This is not valid Torah justice. This is counterfeit “justice”. I have said it many times. Torah justice is appropriate monetary compensation to the injured party as per Bava Kamma 83b. This is what HKBH wants to see. Punishment and retribution, which they are seeking and dressing up as justice, is what the Torah calls nekama and is strictly forbidden.


Ergo, it’s not all about justice. It’s not about justice, at all. It’s about nekama.


Let’s review some of the statements and insert the true intentions, shall we?


Zvi Gluck:


Tonight is about courage. It's about justice nekama… we will hear from someone whose courage helped bring justice nekama… For years, these three sisters fought for justice nekama. Not days, not months, years.


Rabbi Coren:


to be able to come and be able to bring much more emes and justice nekama to the world.


Moshe Frankel:


The challenges, the anguish and despair in seeking justice nekama… even the recognition that sometimes justice nekama fails or doesn't fully, isn't fully meted out…Maybe it won't take 13 years to get justice nekama.


And, Nicole:


Malka Leifer is doing a chillul Hashem by escaping justice nekama, not you… That is something I questioned myself because fighting for justice nekama for so long and at some point, it felt like I was living for justice nekama because of the pain of the delays and all the hardships that my sisters and I went through to try and get that justice nekama.


Doesn’t sound quite as nice, does it?


Incidentally, Nicole actually received monetary compensation (see timeline HERE), but it was from the school that did nothing wrong to her, not from Mrs. Leifer.


Once we acknowledge that all this “justice” is counterfeit, and that we are talking about nekama sugar-coated to look respectable, the entire 1-hour 52-minute presentation falls like a house of cards. As such, let us review these remarks:


42:40


and finally we heard that Yaakov Litzman was involved in obstructing justice in telling the psychiatrists to falsify records and that is what we were fighting against that we did not even know that level of corruption.


If it were really justice, this conduct would be very "corrupt". But he wasn’t obstructing “justice”. He was obstructing nekama. He was obstructing unwarranted mesira, gonev nefesh, lo tasgir, and additional chillul Hashem. Falsifying records is usually a corrupt, loathsome enterprise, but to save a Jew from mesira, extradition and unjustified shame and incarceration, it becomes a mitzvah. This is where לא תעמוד על דם רעיך  truly applies.


Rabbi Litzman put his career and good name on the line to do it and he suffered for it. But, to me and to HKBH, he is a hero.


Of course, to Nicole Meyer, Rabbi Coren, Moshe Frankel, to Zvi Gluck, and to most of the Jewish consumer world, he is a miscreant worthy of shame and humiliation. And so, they make sure to spew out as much sinas chinam as possible in the name of nekama justice.


Again, in my frenzy to be dan l’kaf zechus, I gave them all an opportunity to explain themselves and to educate me. Maybe I am the one in the wrong. So, I asked them. I also told Zvi Gluck that if he cannot justify his sinas chinam, he needs to publicly apologize to Rabbi Litzman and to whomever else.


Here is the 5th and last email (to date). It is dated May 6, 2026. I am pasting it with all the trimmings. Note the subject line “Please End the Sinas Chinam”. I used this subject line on all of the emails.

 

 

 

Please End the Sinas Chinam Cont'd - Grand Finale

 

 May 6, 2026, 2:25 PM

 





Yechezkel Hirshman <1a7b.author@gmail.com>


to Zvi, zgluck, info@18forshay.com, necmeyer, info, rabbidac@gmail.com



BSD

 

Hello Reb Zvi, LOY”T

 

Shalom u’bracha.


Once again, thank you for your swift non-reply. I see this entire exchange as a clear display of your lack of backbone and avoidance of accountability.


We now reach the crux of this entire series of emails. I saw your talks and I was thoroughly appalled by the cynical motzi laaz and sinas chinam that you displayed. I hold that you need to take accountability for it.


From our previous emails we have established the following.


  • We have established that false accusations really happen. There is no dispute on this.

  • We have established that Malka Leifer never confessed to any wrongdoing. Further, that the court did not establish that the alleged crimes actually occurred (HERE).

  • You failed to present any reason why any objective outsider should be convinced that she is guilty, even though I asked you to do so.

  • We established that if there is no case of rodef in the Leifer episode and, as such, there are no grounds to permit any mesira.

  • We established that extradition of any Jewish person away from EY is totally forbidden without exception.

  • We established that pursuit of punishment is not pursuing “justice”. As such, the “obstruction” of punishment [especially when unwarranted] cannot be called an “obstruction of justice”.

  • Now let me add another fact. There is no allegation that Rabbi Yaakov Litzman made any attempt whatsoever to obstruct any kind of justice. He only attempted to obstruct extradition which is forbidden by Jewish law.

In light of all of the above, can you please explain to the world what Rabbi Yaakov Litzman did wrong???


Rabbi Yaakov Litzman., in his legitimate effort to save a Jewish Israeli citizen who had not been convicted of any wrongdoing from extradition, wrongful mesira, and wrongful goyishe “justice”, not only did nothing wrong, but did what any Torah observant Jew is obligated, not permitted, but obligated to do. What he did is the epitome of לא תעמוד על דם רעיך.


Am I wrong?


If I am wrong, now is the time to grow a backbone and to explain to me, and to the world, why I am wrong and why it is acceptable to publicly slander, shame and crucify a G-d fearing Jew such as Rav Yaakov Litzman for doing the right thing?


If you cannot do this, I think you owe a public retraction and apology and [public] entreaty for mechila to Rav Yaakov Litzman for being מוציא לעז and מוציא שם רע against him.


So, at this time, you have three choices:


  1. Explain exactly what Yaakov Litzman did wrong in the eyes of the Torah and yashrut. IOW, prove me wrong.

  2. Publicly renounce your vicious slander and ask mechila from those affected.

  3. Do nothing and continue promulgating your motzi shem rah and sinas chinam עד מאה ועשרים  and beyond.

Which will it be?


While you are at it, I think it behooves you to also make a public entreaty of mechila to all the anonymous Rabbanim that you collectively shamed despite the fact that the Torah really does restrict our options to prosecute accused offenders. You callously stated that their use of the Torah is meant “to silence victims”. Can you please explain why a posture to uphold the rights of an accused person needs to be maliciously couched as an endeavor “to silence the victims” (who are really only alleged victims)?


Once again awaiting your prompt response.


If you reply to me promptly and directly, we may be able to avoid posting these letters on the Internet.


Hatzlacha rabba v’kol tuv, sela.


Very sincerely yours,

 

Yechezkel Hirshman

  

Please note - This correspondence and all responses and subsequent ones are not confidential. You may show them to whoever you like and I may do the same including discussing them on my blog if the need arises.

 

No, he did not respond. He did not save me the trouble of posting these letters on the Internet. Accordingly, his choice in my multiple choice challenge is choice 3 – Do nothing and continue promulgating your motzi shem rah and sinas chinam עד מאה ועשרים  and beyond.

 

I cannot respect his cowardly choice and I can no longer respect him.


Nicole Meyer is full of hatred and it is contagious. She has infected some very sincere, well-meaning people. She has infected all of Amudim and Beis Medrash Ohr HaChaim and anyone else who gives her 'a standing ovation'.


Nicole can do it properly, if she wants. She can be a mentor and inspiration to victims of SA, but only if she teaches them to heal and not to hate. She could talk about her episodes of alleged abuse in an educational way, but not in a personal way. There is no need to identify the abuser and certainly no need to demonize her and certainly to demonize G-d fearing people who see things differently than she does and who tried to prevent her from doing all the damage that she caused.


Zvi Gluck claims that Amudim has helped over 20,000 people. I think that number sounds a bit exaggerated, but I cannot dispute it. Amudim comes across as a wonderful life-saving organization that does great work and it should continue to do so. But it can all be done without the sinas chinam and without idolizing hate-filled, vengeance seeking, mosrim. The entire March 8 presentation is one colossal chillul Hashem. It needs to be taken off their website.


For those who like to preach ובערת הרע מקרבך, the word מקרבך actually means the evil that is in one’s own heart and soul. And the first place to look is where it says: לא תשנא את אחיך בלבבך.


No comments:

Printfriendly

Print Friendly and PDF

Translate